“If a cluttered desk is a sign of a cluttered mind, of what, then, is an empty desk?” ~Albert Einstein
I’m gearing up to clear out my home office, and for me a hefty part of that process involves kicking and screaming against the mere prospect of doing it. Hence, today’s post, in which I become defensive about my clutter.
When I chanced upon this picture of Al Gore in his office (at right) and noted the spectacular state of his desk, my first reaction was, “One of my people!” (My second was, “What’s with the giant frog art, Al?”)
I felt instantly supported in my long-held belief that countless smart and successful people manage just fine with clutter. According to Ajilon Office, a professional staffing firm, this belief is not merely wishful thinking. Their research has found that “office messiness tends to increase sharply with increased education, salary, and experience.” (Which I guess accounts for why Mr. Gore’s desk makes mine look neat as a pin.)
Despite the fact that many high achievers do their high achieving amid slippery stacks of paper, there’s a whole lotta shaming going on when it comes to clutter. Naturally, a lot of the tsk-tsking is perpetrated by the booming home-organizing industry, which the New York Times says is projected to reach $7.6 billion by 2009.
Authors Eric Abrahamson and David H. Freedman, in their book A Perfect Mess: The Hidden Benefits of Disorder (due out in paperback on January 1st), attempt to combat the current home-organizing hysteria with reasoned arguments in support of disorder. While Abrahamson and Freedman do not advocate hoarding and concede a space must have enough room for the occupant to actually work, they also contend that people who tend toward a cluttered desk also tend to get loads accomplished (the piles are just a retraceable trail of work flow).
In an interview with the New York Times, the authors purport, “Mess is complete, in that it embraces all sorts of random elements. Mess tells a story: you can learn a lot about people from their detritus, whereas neat—well, neat is a closed book. Neat has no narrative and no personality.”
Even further, they argue, too much organization inhibits creativity. In an article in Inc.com, Freedman says, “When things are carefully arranged and kept in their ‘proper’ time and place and done in precisely the ‘right’ way every time, you lock out some highly useful qualities—such as improvisation, adaptability, and serendipity.” One of many examples cited is that of Alexander Fleming, whose cluttered laboratory desk held a moldy petri dish that led him to discover penicillin.
So here’s to piles of paper and moldy petri dishes! You never know what great discoveries might lie within.
Photo: Al Gore in his office (Steve Pyke for Time).
Recent Comments